Delegation of Gujarat Legislative Congress Party, under the leadership of Gujarat Pradesh Congress Committee President Mr.Arjunbhai Modhwadiya, Gujarat Congress Legislative Party Leader Mr.Shaktisinh Gohil and AICC Gujarat In-Charge Shri Mohan Prakash and Co in-charge and MP Shri Ashok Tanwar with MPs & MLAs from Gujarat are also met today Her Excellency Mrs.Pratibha Devisinh Patil and submitted a detailed representation with 1000 pages of documents on various scams worth Rs.1 lakh crores by Gujarat Bhartiya Janata Party Government headed by Shri Narendra Modi, and demanded inquiry of these scandals through independent investigation agencies.
The representation submitted stated that the Narendra Modi Government has made futile attempt to make people outside Gujarat unaware about reality by creating hype of development and good governance. It has been demanded in the representation that investigation be carried out through independent agency since investigations in corruption are not being carried out by investigation agencies ofGujaratsince they are made inert.
The several documents submitted along with the representation with detailed note are enclosed herewith.
1. Land allotment with meager rate to industrialist in capital Gandhinagar without auction
2. Land allotment with meager rate to industrialist in capital Gandhinagar without auction. Land acquired for the Capital Project is mainly used for the purpose of establishment of Government infrastructure including housing Assembly and the State Secretariat and allied offices. More and above, residential plots are allotted in selected sectors to State Government employees and priority social sectors. The lands are not being sold to any private parties keeping in view future requirement of the State infrastructures. In some of the cases when properties are proposed to be sold to the private parties it is being sold by holding public auction only. Giving said process go by, following industries have been allotted lands at throw away or meager price, details whereof have been set out in the
Total loss to the treasury due to above-mentioned land allotment to the industries is worked out to be Rs.51,97,16,22,317 crores.
Under the Right to Information Act, details of aforesaid allotments were sought from the concerned Department of Government of Gujarat. Certain data have also been collected so as to substantiate what is stated hereinabove
1. Rs.33,000 crores concession to Tata Nano Car Project
Tata Motors Ltd. has established Nano Car Project at Sanand, Ahmedabad. The total project cost is Rs.2200 crores. Said project was proposed to be established initially at Singur, West Bengalwhich is now shifted to Gujarat after a clandestine understanding with Tata Motors Ltd. and the Chief Minister of Gujarat. It is stated that the whole project was negotiated by Ms. Neera Radia. The astonishing fact of the said project is that the cost of relocation from Singur to Sanand,Gujarat is of Rs.700 crores. The total project cost including shipping cost was projected to be Rs.2900 crores, however, corruption is done in the aforesaid negotiated project, details whereof are as follows:-
1100 acres of land has been allotted without auction to Tata Motors @ Rs.900/- per sq.mtr. Cost of the land recovered is Rs.400 crores whereas market rate of the said land is about Rs.10,000/- per sq.mtr. Tata Motor has been given facility of payment of said land cost by installment of Rs.50 crores each at the interval of every 6 months. This land was originally belong to the Government of Gujarat which was reserved for Veterinary University. It was dereserved by a stroke of pen overnight and allotted to Tata Motors without following due process and without any transparency.
The loan of Rs.9,570/- crores has been given to Tata Motors
@ 0.10% interest with moratorium of 20 years. It may be noted that that the total cost of the said project is stated to be Rs.2200 crores, against that total project cost, a loan of Rs.9570/- crores has been given which is more than 4.25 times more. It may be noted that no financial institution will, in any circumstances, grant loan more than 100% of the total project cost. In ordinary circumstances, finance would be 70 to 80%, depending upon credit-worthiness of the loanee. That is a sound principle of finance being followed worldwide.
More and above, the Government has exempted Tata Motors from payment of Stamp Duty, Registration Charges on the conveyance or transfer of lands and also provided free of cost two to four land roads connectivity from the State Highway to the project site.
More and above, the Government of Gujarat has also promised acquisition of land for rail connectivity upto DMIC to the Tata Motors and also agreed to provide land for ancillary industries and established all infrastructures for electric power including installation of 220 KVa power supply through Double Circuited Feeder and the Tata Motors is exempted from payment of Electricity Duty. Tata Motors has been provided with 1400 cubic liters water per day at the project site and also permitted to draw ground water for immediate need. Said project is in a Dark Zone and therefore, no farmer is permitted to draw sub-soil water. No fresh electric connections are given to even farmers for drawl of subsoil water. Water table of the said area is highly disturbed and salinity ingress is very high in subsoil water. The Government has also agreed to provide facilities for disposal of hazardous waste and also permission for disposal of treated waste water and agreed to develop Transport Nagar on the principle ofPPP– Public Private Participation.
The Government has also proposed to acquire 100 acres of land forTownshipofTata Motorsand also agreed to provide facilities for laying down of the Natural Gas Pipeline from point of supply till the site.
In the aforesaid project, the Government of Gujarat and the State exchequer is suffering loss of Rs.33,000 crores. It is stated that in one Nano Car produced in Sanand plant, State Government contribution is more than Rs.60,000/-, so, for every car produced in Tata Motor plant, Gujarat tax payer looses Rs.60,000/- which is continuous loss. This is not a transparent deal. Few hundred crores of rupees have been exchanged in granting such permission and all the details were kept under the sleeves at the time when the project was inaugurated by Chief Minister Narendra Modi in presence of the Ratan Tata and Neera Radia. No details were disclosed at the relevant time. Only after application was submitted under the Right to Information Act, certain facts have been disclosed, however, full facts are not forthcoming. This is a clandestine well-designed, meticulously executed corrupt deal which deserves investigation. In support of the aforesaid contentions, relevant material so far made available under the Right to Information Act and collected from other sources, including photographs of the Chief Minister, Ms. Neera Radia and Mr. Ratan Tata showing their closeness.
2. Land allotment to Adani Group for Mundra Port & Mundra Special Economic Zone (SEZ)
Mr. Narendra Modi, Chief Minister of Gujaratyielded Adani group direct benefit of few thousand crores of rupees. Said group has been allotted 3,86,83,079 sq.mtrs. of land which has been allotted in the year 2003 and 2004. Total price recovered from the said group is
Rs.46,03,16,292/- These lands have been allotted at a throw away price. The lands have been allotted @ Rs.1/- per sq.mtr. and lastly
@ Rs.32/- per sq.mtrs. However, most of the land is allotted at the rate in single digit; there are few instances where the rate has been charged in double digit, details whereof reduced in tabular form is enclosed. The land acquired at the rate of Rs.1/- per sq.mtr. and the highest rate at Rs.32/- per sq.mtrs., after demarcating said land into sub-plots of few thousand square meters, have been allotted to more than one public sector companies at the rate of Rs.800/- to Rs.10,000/- per sq.mtrs. Except providing for the roads, no further development has been done by Adani Group. It may be noted that for providing roads, 16 to 22% of the land at the most are required to be earmarked for the purpose of communication, in residential zones. In industrial zones, the area of roads would contribute to about 10% of the total area since size of the plots would be in thousand square meters and not in 100 sq.mtrs. Therefore, in development of the roads, there cannot be increase of the cost of 100% than the original acquisition price. Therefore, the land acquired at the rate of Rs.1/- per sq.mtr., after providing roads, the cost of said land would become Rs.2 or Rs.3 per sq.mtrs. whereas these lands have been allotted on lease to the public sector undertakings at the rate of Rs.800/- to Rs.10,000/- per sq.mtrs. The loss to the public exchequer applying principle of res ipso locuitor would be Rs.10,000 crores, details whereof reduced in tabular form and details provided under the Right to Information Act.
3. Allotment of Prime Land of Navsari Agricultural University (NAU) without auction for 7 star hotel to M/s. Chhatrala (India) Hotel Group Ltd.
Chhatrala Group is one of the most favored company by the Government of Gujarat. InSuratcity, the land was donated by farmers for establishment of the Seed Farm for about 108 years ago. A well-known seed farm was developed where various research projects were undertaken in past and which was one of the leading research centre in the agriculture in all over the country. SinceSurattown has developed very fast and growth rate of the Surat town is fastest in the country, said area is surrounded from all directions by fully developed residential colonies. Therefore, said land of the Seed Farm has become of a prime location and prime property inSurattown. The property is owned by Navsari Agriculture University (NAU) which is one of the bifurcated university of Gujarat Agriculture University.
This fraud is committed by the Chief Minister and every details whereof was monitored until allotment has been made and the possession has been given, by office of the Chief Minister ofGujarat. NAU was never wanted to part with the said property since it has established its prime location for the agriculture research projects. Said land was demanded just one year back by Surat Municipal Corporation for establishment of its project for water supply plant. The university did not agree to part with the said land and the Corporation was not given said land for public purpose.
Said Chhatrala Industries approached Chief Minister and requested for allotment of suitable land for project of a Seven-Star Hotel. In pursuance thereof, the Chief Minister issued direction in writing to allot said industry land required by it. The Collector, Surat, initially showed four different sites, however, said entrepreneur declined to accept any one of it. Prime location of project of Seed Farm of Agriculture University was shown as the suitable land by the said industry for establishment of its Seven-Star Hotel. It is stated that said industry wanted to invest Rs.500 crores for establishment of said Seven-Star Hotel. The Collector, Surat informed said industry that said NAU land is not under control of office of the Collector, Surat; land is under control of Agriculture Department and therefore, said department is required to be approached. It appears that the industry has approached the Chief Minister again and under his direction, the Ministry of Agriculture and the Ministry of Revenue have acted at a jet speed; divested said land allotted to the University without concurrence of the University and revested in the Revenue Department and thereafter, Collector was directed to allot said land. Initially, the Principal Secretary of the Government of Gujarat, Revenue Department, vide his communication dated June 18, 2005, suggested to allot said piece of land admeasuring 65,000 sq.mtrs. at the rate of Rs.15,000/- per sq.mtrs. The Surat Municipal Corporation demanded Rs.44,000/- per sq.mtrs. of the land which was declined by communication dated November 5, 2006. But, Chhatrala Industries was sought to be allotted at throw away price, farmers approached the court and said that if their land is sold in public auction, the price of about
Rs.1 lakh per sq.mtr. would be fetched. The consensus recorded before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India when the matter was taken before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India which was listed before the First Court at the relevant time, where Government of Gujarat has given consent for increasing price from Rs.15,000/- per sq.mtr. to Rs.35,000/- per sq.mtr. i.e. at the 1/3 price of the market rate of said land. This project is a clear case of a fraud and corruption. This was brokered by the Chief Minister through his office. The Government could have earned about Rs.650/- crores from sale of said piece of the land, said property has been sold for Rs.224/- crores. Unfortunately, floor of the Augustinstitute ofHon’ble Supreme Court ofIndia is used in brokering said fraud and fraudulent deal.
4. Illegal allotment and construction on Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) and Forest Land by Essar Group
Another favored company of the Chief Minister is ESSAR Group. The land bearing survey no. 434 of Hazira (Suvali) admeasuring 2,07,60,000 sq.mtrs. has been allotted which is consisted partly of CRZ and the Forest land. As per the guideline issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, no land can be permitted to be developed by anybody in CRZ and Forest land which has been allotted at a throw away price. It may be noted that when this land was allotted to Essar Group which was a forest land, the Deputy Conservator of Forests, Vyara recorded a Forest Offence being CR-II No.2 of 2006 for the offence punishable under the Indian Forest Act, 1927. 4 different offences have been recorded and same has been settled by imposing of fine of Rs.20 lakhs. Illegal constructions carried out in the said forest land has been directed to be removed and demolished and land directed to be restored to the Forest Department. However, since occupier is unauthorized occupier and encroacher is Essar, therefore, no actions are being taken by the State machinery and Essar peacefully enjoy said piece of land with encroachment. The market rate of land I more than Rs.3,000 per sq.mtr. Total cost of the land at this rate worked out Rs.6,228 Crores. This a loss to Government over and above loss to environment.
5. Huge Land allotment for Salt Chemicals near Pakistan Border to the Companies said to be related to Venkaiya Naiduji (BJP Leader)
Chief Minister of Gujarat, Mr. Narendra Modi was in a doldrums since he was facing internal resistance from his own political party in the year 2004 onwards. The ex-Chief Minister Mr. Keshubhai Patel supported the opponents of Mr. Narendra Modi. Mr. Vankaiyya Naidu was the President of All India Bhartiya Janta Party at the relevant time. The Chief Minister wanted his support for his political survival. So as to favor Mr. Vankaiyaa Naidu, a group of companies where Mr. Vankaiyaa Naidu has said to have direct or indirect interest, have been favored by the Chief Minister. Several companies have been allotted lands in coastal area of Kutch District. Once upon a time, allotment of this land, as per my information, was objected by the Central Security agencies since allotment of these pieces of land would be threat or compromise national security. Location of the said land is situated nearby No Man’s Zone of international boarder of Pakistan. Therefore, to obviate objections of national security agencies, a false document appears to have been made.
It was represented that the coastal land are being allotted for production of salt and the companies which has said to have interest of Mr. Vankaiyaa Naidu, have represented falsely that they propose to produce salt-based chemicals which are substitute of import materials and the chemicals and therefore, it would be in the national interest to allot said piece of land to the said group of companies to save foreign exchange.
The lands have been allotted to Archean Chemicals Ltd. admeasuring 24,021 hector, and to Solaris Chem-tech admeasuring 26,746 acres at the rent of Rs.150/- per hector per year.
6. Bharat Hotels Ltd.
Prime Land allotment without Auction to Bharat Hotels Ltd. at Sarkhej-Gandhinagar Highway at Ahmedabad is considered to be the costliest city as far as commercial land and residential land is concerned. M/s.Bharat Hotel Ltd. intends to establish a 5-Star Hotel at very busy and commercially important Sarkhej-Gandhinagar Highway. At the behest of Mr.Narendra Modi, the Chief Minister of Guajrat, this very group has been favored by allotment of land admeasuring 21,300 sq.mtrs. at the rate of Rs.4,424/- per sq.mtr. The present market rate of this land is considered to be Rs.1 lakh per sq.mtr. if this particular plot is auctioned, the Government of Gujarat might have fetched amount of Rs.213 crores. Therefore, it is found that in this particular deal, the State Government sustained loss of Rs.203 crores.
7. Land allotment to various industries/industrialists for setting up industrial units near major cities
Government of Gujarathas organized Investment Summits in the year 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009 and 2011. It is pertinent to note that most of the industries who have made MOU with Government of Gujarat for setting up industries have demanded land in the vicinity of district headquarter cities. This particular land is very costly land. The State Government might have auctioned this land, but only to favor certain industries/ industrialists, they have given the land at throw away prices. List of industries and other details are attached herewith for ready reference
8. Allotment of fishing rights in various dams without Auction
It was policy of the State Government to give fishing rights of the dams by auction only. But, in the year 2008, Agriculture and Fisheries Ministers have decided to give rights without auction to the favored parties and accordingly, fishing rights of 38 dams have been given at throw away prices at Rs.3,53,780/-. The aggrieved parties have approached Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat and Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat has struck down decision of the Ministers and consequently Fisheries Department of Government ofGujaratmade auction for the fishing rights and fetched price of Rs.15 crores. It is very unfortunate that the Minister who had made this illegal order is not removed from the Ministry of Mr. Narendra Modi. Name of the said Minister is Mr. Purushottam Solanki.
9. Prime Land allotment with thro away rate, without Auction to L&T at Hazira, Surat
Larsen & Toubro is also favored by the Chief Minister, Gujarat. 8,00,000 sq.mtrs. of land is allotted to the said company in Hazira at the rate of Rs.1/- per sq.mtr. Out of 8,50,000 sq.mtrs. of the land has been allotted at the rate of Rs.700/- per sq.mtrs. At the similar time, other persons have requested for allotment of the land. Same company has been allotted land @ Rs.1000/- per sq.mtrs. from land bearing survey no.446/A of Suvali (Hazira) and by another allotment dated October 23, 2008, another land admeasuring 2,57,867 sq.mtrs of same survey number has been allotted at the rate of Rs.700/- per sq.mtrs. against the price fixed by the land committee at the rate of Rs.950/- per sq.mtr. This property is at prime location in the industrial zone of Hazira. This property cost worth more than 5 times more than the price recovered form the company even at rate of Rs.700/- and Rs.1000/- per sq.mtrs. The land allotted at the rate of Rs.1/- per sq.mtr. and property of 8,00,000 sq.mtrs. is just gifted by the Chief Minister to the said company. Few hundred crores of rupees is cost of the said land which is allotted in Rs.80 lakhs only. This cannot be simply done unless the Chief Minister himself is bribed.
10. Cattle Feed Froud
The Government of Gujarat purchased Cattle Feed from different companies. Such cattle feed are stated to be mineral food. In ordinary circumstances, any purchase by the Government or its agency is by adopting transparent procedure inviting tenders. In case of purchase of mineral mixture cattle feed, the company which was black-listed has been given order of purchase which was placed at the rate of Rs.240/- per 5 KGs whereas market rate is of Rs.120/- to Rs.140/-. Amount of Rs.9 crores has been paid more in the said purchase. Said action was challenged before Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat by way of preferring a writ petition being Special Civil Application No.10875 of 2010. Said petition was taken up for hearing by the Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat wherein Government admitted that transparency was not maintained in ordering the purchase and therefore, punitive action would be taken against responsible persons. However, since Hon’ble Agriculture Minister Mr. Dilip Sanghani is involved, no actions are being taken.
11. Scam in supplementary Nutrition Extruded Fortified Blended food (EFBF) to Anganwadi centers in the State
Under the scheme of Government of India, the Government of Gujarat invited tenders to supply pre-mix of EFBF food i.e. ready to cook by the Commissioner, Women and Child Development,GujaratState. Accordingly, following 4 companies have submitted bids :-
(1) Kota Dal Mill Company,Kota, Rajasthan
(2) Murliwala Agro Product, Udaypur, Rajasthan
(3) Suruchi Food Pvt.Ltd., Gurgaon, Haryana
(4) Cambridge Health Care Ltd., Mehsana,Gujarat
As per the offer for 5 different zones, the bids have been received from 4 companies. One combined offer was received from Cambridge Health Care, a Gujarat based company whereas 3 offers were received from Kota Dal Mill, Murliwala Agro Products and Suruchi Food Pvt. Ltd. Kota Dal Mill and Suruchi Food are sister-concern though basis have been shown at Rajasthan and Haryana, respectively. Cambridge Health Care made offer for all 5 zones for Rs.408 crores. Said contractor was supplying said food earlier and qualified. So as to favor non-Gujarati company, tender of Cambridge Health Care was disqualified and against offer of Rs.408 crores, offers of single zone were accepted leaving single tender for the single zone. As per the Central Vigilance Commission guidelines, if the offer has been received from the single tenderer, said offers are not to be accepted and tenders are required to be re-invited. Though combined offer of Cambridge Health Care was there, offers of 3 companies are accepted for total of Rs.588.89 crores. The offer was Rs.180.79 crores more than single offer made by Cambridge Health Care. Private negotiations stated to have been made and offer has been accepted for Rs.500 crores i.e. Rs.92 crores have been given more than the offers of Cambridge Health Care. This nutrient food is meant for expecting mothers and infants.
14. Gujarat State Petroleum Corporation
GSPC Limited is stated to be a Navratna company of GujaratState, which has been allotted right of exploration for production of oil and gas. It has been stated that the said company could find out million of cubic meter gas reserves and future of Gujaratwould be changed by the said company. It was also stated that the Gujaratwould become hub of petroleum products. The company has invested about Rs.4933.50 crores by taking loan from various resources. The company stated to have acquired rights of exploration in 51 domestic zones out of which the company could get positive result in 13 blocks. Several thousand million cubic gas deposit has been explored by the said company, were the headlines given by the Chief Minister at the top of his voice and the pitch and it was stated that the GSPC would be one singular company which would transform future of Gujarat and Gujarat would become centre and hub for oil production in the entire nation. After the said advertisement, as on March 31, 2009, 10.66 mmbc oil and 28.72 BCFgas has been explored and the total production of oil is Rs.98 crores whereas gas production is of Rs.199 crores. Therefore, total earning of GSPC is Rs.290 crores against investment of Rs.3933.50 crores. The GSPC has entered into an agreement with one Geo-Global, a multi-national company. Under what circumstances said agreement is entered into is one of the mystery. Therefore, this requires detailed investigation since either the oil and gas is not found andGujarat public and the nation has been mislead or there is a definite storage of gas and oil reserves. However, deliberately, no production activity are being undertaken so that said company can be converted into sick unit and can be sold at throw way price with all its reserves and thousand of crores of rupees can be earned by selling such rights. Contractual relations of Geo-Global and GSPC deserves investigations since terms of such contract provides that machineries of Geoglobal is to be hired by GSPC and for which, hire charges are to be paid by GSPC over and above the profit sharing. If the company is doing joint venture, the company shall bear proportionate responsibility in investment, profit and loss. If the company is providing service, then the company is entitled for hire charges only. But, hire charge sand profits both are unknown to the economic world.
15. Utilization of Private Luxury Jet Aircraft and Helicopter by Chief Minister at the cost beneficiary industries
Government ofGujarathas their own one 12 seater Jet Aircraft and luxury Helicopter. Generally, this fleet were used by CM and the H.E. the Governor where regular commercial flights are not available. Up to 2003 all CMs have used commercial flights for theirDelhi, Mumbai and overseas visit and State aircraft/helicopter in other visits.
But Chief Minister Narendra Modi is not comfortable with Government owned Aircraft/Helicopter and commercial flights. He managed to keep Ultra Modern Luxury Jet/Helicopter ready to fly any where in the country/state when needed at the cost of beneficiary industrialists. In overseas trips, He used to travel with the head of industrial houses in chartered luxury jet aircraft at the expenses of such industrialists. Initially, Govt. of Gujarat have refused to give details of such trips using private aircraft but when Airport Authority of India have given details under RTI, CMO have supplied such details.
This free luxury jet/helicopter air services provided by industrialists are one type of corruption and should be investigated accordingly. Chief Minister have availed free aircraft/helicopter services to the tune of Rs.50 crores. In five years it exceeds more than 200 trips.
16. Sujalam Suflam Yojana scam of Water Resources Ministry
Chief Minister Narendra Modi announced Rs.6237.33 crores Sujlam Suflam Yojana (SSY) in the year 2003 to win parliamentary elections. The scheme included to provide irrigation and water supply facilities toNorth Gujaratand was planned to complete it within 2 years i.e. in 2005.
Out of various works of SSY, work component of Rs.2063.96 crores was instrusted to state owned Gujarat Water Resources Development Corporation Ltd. (GWRDC) with a stipulation to complete it before December, 2005. Chief Minister have ordered to allot this work to GWRDC only to avoid the open competitive bidding and CAG audit. Expenditure of Rs.1127.64 crores have been incurred upto 2008. Public Accounts Committee of Gujarat Assembly Unanimously prepared report having scam of more than Rs.500 crores. Government have not allowed to table it in house. CAG in their 16 page report have elaborated various financial irregularities. After so many public uproar, Govt. transferred secretary of water resources and appointed committee consisting 3 secretaries to investigate the scam. Still reports are not submitted.
It is pertinent to note that SSY Scheme still not completed which was to complete in 2005.
17. 36.25 acre farm land in Kutch District purchase & sell by M/s. Indigold Refinery Ltd., Mumbai by direct intervention of CMO & Hon’ble Minister (Revenue), violating all law.
In 2003, M/s. Indigold Refinery Ltd., Mumbai have acquired 39.25 acre land (two lacks M2) in village Kukma and Moti Reldi Bhuj-Kutch District from farmers under clause-63 of Mumbai Tenancy & farm land Management (Vidarbh and Kutchh) for establishing industry. Under the act, collector Kutchh has given certificate to purchase farm land and establish industrial unit with in 6 months from the date of purchase. This time limit may be extended for further 3 years i.e. maximum extension available under the law. If promoters/industrial house fails to establish the unit within 3 years than this lands deems to be transferred to the Government.
The said Indigold Refinery neither established industry nor sought extension for 3 years available under the act. Even though under political pressure, collector not initiated any action to take possession of land.
On 18-06-2009 Allumina Refinery Mumbai have represented to Hon’ble Chief Minister to allow Indigold Refinery Ltd., to sell the said land to alumina Refinery Ltd., CMO has asked the revenue department to take action on the representation.
On this instruction of CMO, file has been prepared. But from section officer to Principal Secretary of Revenue Department stated in file that there is no provision of law to allow transfer/sell of such farm land. Revenue Department has suggested taking possession of land by Government only. Ignoring all file noting of administration, Hon’ble Anandiben Patel (Minister of Revenue) have ordered on file “to give clearance to sell of land as special case”. Department of Revenue again resubmitted the file with noting that it is contrary to law to allow such direct sell to the company, instead Government should take possession and than transfer/sell it to Allumina Ltd. or alternatively Government should take 50% unearned profit from Indigold. But Mrs. Anandiben Patel, under instruction from CMO, again ordered to allow the Indigold to sell the said land. This is a unique case of corruption, violating law & benefit to pet industrialist. It should be investigated by CBI.
18. Swan Energy
Swan Energy - another blatant example of corruption is in respect of non-transparent corrupt deal with one Swan Energy.
It is known that worldwide, there is awareness of climatic changes. Increase of carbon level in the atmosphere is a global concern. Increase in carbon level warns atmosphere and heat wave is expected. 49% of share of Pipavav Power Station of GSPC has been sold to Swan Energy without inviting any tender. It was a total opaque deal, there is no question of any transparency. 70% share of the carbon credit has been given to Swan Energy. By virtue of said deal, Swan Energy will earn profit of Rs.12,000 crores against investment of Rs.380 crores only. Swan Energy is a new concerned, had no experience or any repute in any industry sector. These two deals in respect of Swan Energy, were supervised by the Chief Minister Office. A good chunk of fund exchanged hands which is apparent from the nature of the deal. Anybody earns more than 30-times in a short span, would not be earning without greasing hands.
The delegation met the President today also consisted of Congress party’s Members of Parliament and Members of Legislative Assembly.